1. Look at their work, not just their website
Anyone can have a pretty website. Ask for published projects and listen to or watch them in full, not just the trailer. Look at four things:
- Sound: clear voices, steady volume and no noise.
- Editing: pace, clean cuts and well-integrated music.
- Range: whether they've worked with different clients and formats.
- Consistency between cover art, identity and content.
2. They should start by asking why
A production company that's going to support you through the process will ask what you want the podcast for, who you're talking to and how you'll know it's working.
They may only handle the technical side, which is fine, but bear it in mind.
3. Be clear about what's included
Two quotes with the same total can have nothing in common. If you need them to do everything, from idea to distribution, get it in writing:
Every item is explained in how much it costs to produce a podcast.
4. Where it's recorded
Some production companies have their own studio and others come to your office or hire a set. Neither is better in itself: your space gives you comfort and saves travel, and a studio gives you controlled acoustics. What matters is that they explain how they'll guarantee quality either way.
5. The feed and accounts, in your name
It's the most overlooked point and the one that hurts most later. The hosting, the RSS feed and the profiles on Spotify, Apple Podcasts and iVoox must be in your name or your company's.
6. The people behind it
Is the person you're talking to the one who'll do the work? Ask who'll be there on the day of the shoot and who'll edit. And ask about their experience in communication, scripting and interviewing, not just sound. A team that knows how to put a guest at ease improves the result more than any microphone.
7. Process, video, price and trust
- Process and deadlines. A production company should explain every stage: meeting, proposal, schedule, drafts, review and publishing. Ask for the deadlines in writing and what happens if a recording has to be redone.
- Video and promotion. If you're interested in video, check that they work with several cameras, lighting and picture editing, and that they prepare vertical clips. More in what is a video podcast.
- A clear price. Be wary of a price far below everyone else's and of extras that turn up halfway through. You should know from the start what you'll pay and why.
- Trust. A podcast is a long relationship. Consider whether they listen to you and tell you what you need to hear, not just what you want to hear.
Questions for the first meeting
- Can you show me a project similar to mine?
- Who will be my contact, and who edits?
- What exactly does the quote include?
- Where is it recorded, and with what equipment?
- Whose name will the feed and accounts be in?
- How many revisions do I get per episode?
- How long does each episode take to deliver?
- Will you help with promotion?
- What happens if I want to carry on by myself one day?
Warning signs
And one advantage of going local: with a team in Barcelona you can meet in person, record in your office and sort out any surprises the same day, which really shows when there's video, lighting and several people to coordinate.
To sum up
Choose based on proven work, clarity about what's included, ownership of your accounts and the trust the people inspire. Everything else can be learned along the way.